A Quick Checklist for Nonprofits in Summer Brand Design

Summer brand design can help nonprofits connect with their communities. Whether you’re planning an event, launching a campaign, or simply staying active on social media your community is experiencing summertime. But as you roll out seasonal content, it’s easy to lose sight of your visual identity in favor of wanting sunny graphics and beachy vibes.

The good news? You don’t have to choose between on-brand and in-season. With a few thoughtful design tweaks, your nonprofit can show up in a fresh, summery way that still feels aligned with your mission.

Here’s a quick checklist to help your nonprofit “summer-ize” its branding without losing consistency or clarity.

Brighten, Don’t Rebrand

Add seasonal accents to your existing color palette rather than swapping it out completely.

• Use brighter tints of your core brand colors for a lighter, more summery feel.
• Try incorporating one or two accent colors. Think of colors like coral, teal, lemon, or sky blue as limited-time highlights in graphics or event materials.
• Keep your logo colors consistent (or only minimally altered for special campaigns) to maintain recognition.

Lighten the Mood with Summer Brand Design

Summer is emotional so use that. Even if your nonprofit tackles serious issues, this is a good time to balance weight with warmth. Consider some adaptations.

• Swapping heavy headlines for a conversational tone in social posts.
• Using photography with natural light, outdoor settings, or real moments of joy and connection.
• Letting visuals breathe by going lighter on text overlays and allow more white space in designs.

Use Seasonal Imagery That Reflects Your Mission

Yes, it’s easy to reach for stock images of sunglasses and sand, but that may not always be authentic to your work. Instead:

• Show your team or volunteers in action outdoors.
• Highlight your community enjoying a summer program or event.
• Use seasonal elements like gardens, parks, sun, or water but only when they support your message.

Think: “What does summer look like through our mission’s lens?”

Summer Brand Design to Simplify for Shorter Attention Spans

People scroll fast in the summer. They’re outside more, working less, and mentally in vacation mode. This doesn’t mean dumbing down your content, just tightening it up to make it concise.

• Use bold, clear headlines that are easy to read even on mobile.
• Stick to one main call to action per graphic or email.
• Favor short videos, carousels, or infographics over long-form content when appropriate.

Add a Summer Signature with Summer Brand Design

Think of a fun, limited-time design element, action or phrase you can weave into summer content. These additions make your summer content feel intentional and unified without overhauling your whole brand.

• Adding a small sun icon or wave pattern as a visual motif.

• Creating a short tagline like “Powered by Sunshine + Purpose” or “Fueling Change All Summer Long.”
• A seasonal content series like “Summer Spotlights” to feature donors, volunteers, employees or impact stories.

Seasonal Summer Brand Design Doesn’t Mean Off-Brand

Nonprofits don’t have to be brand-strict to be credible. With thoughtful and expressive design, you can bring seasonal energy into your visuals while staying true to your voice, your mission and the people you serve. So go ahead and add a little warmth, a little light and a little summer spirit to your brand. Your audience and your team will feel the difference.

Rework old work this summer, and fine tune it to maximize impact. Not every marketing campaign soars on the first try: some fizzle out quietly, lost in the noise of busy inboxes or drowned by shifting algorithms. But summer isn’t just for new campaigns, it’s the perfect time to revisit what didn’t work, rework it, and give it a second chance to shine.

Just like TV networks used to air “summer reruns” to capture fresh audiences, you can reimagine underperforming campaigns with new timing, angles and energy. Because sometimes, the idea was good — just maybe not the execution, the context or the season.

Summer is Primetime for a Reboot Rework

Summer marketing tends to feel lighter, looser and a little more experimental. Audiences are mentally shifting gears, slowing down, traveling, spending time outdoors. Engagement might dip in some channels but spike in others. It’s also when your team might have more breathing room to reflect, regroup, and rework ideas without the Q4 pressure.

Plus, summer is a metaphor-rich season. Think: growth, energy, movement and play. All perfect themes for breathing life into a campaign that maybe didn’t stick the first time.

Review and Rework Without Judgment

Before anything can be reimagined, it needs to be understood. Ask yourself these questions about the campaign.

• What was the goal? Did the campaign aim for awareness, engagement, conversions?
• What worked well? Maybe the visuals were strong, but the CTA was weak. Maybe the story was good, but the audience was wrong.
• What failed and why? Timing? Message mismatch? Channel choice? Lack of clarity?

This isn’t about beating up on your old work. It’s about auditing the content with curiosity and clarity.

Refresh the Angle

Ask yourself what new spin would make this idea more relevant now?

• Update the context? Can you rework the content to connect it to current summer trends, events, or cultural moments?
• Shift the focus? Try telling the same story from a different POV like customer-first, behind-the-scenes or values-driven.
• Simplify it? Strip it down to the strongest insight or benefit and rebuild from there.

Summer is a season when audiences crave ease and emotion. Lean into storytelling that feels breezy, relatable, or joyfully unexpected.

Rework it and Change the Channel

Sometimes, the idea isn’t the problem but the platform is. So a campaign that fell flat as a static Instagram post might thrive as a short-form video. Or, an overlooked blog post might shine as a podcast segment or live Q&A.

Consider a form change-up to maximize your content impact:

• Repackaging email content as a summer-themed downloadable checklist.
• Turning case studies into Instagram carousel “client journeys.”
• Repurposing old webinars into bite-sized reels or quote graphics.

Embrace the Remix

You don’t need to start from scratch in a rework of an old campaign, just remix it. In fact, some of the most iconic campaigns are iterations of past ideas.

• Nike’s Just Do It has been reframed a dozen ways.
• Spotify Wrapped is a reinvention of year-in-review content.
• Coca-Cola constantly reuses its “share” message in seasonal formats.

Take what worked like language, design or sentiment and remix it to fit your audience better this summer.

Failure Isn’t Final, Keep Reworking

Just because something didn’t work the first time doesn’t mean it’s a bad idea. It might’ve just been early. Or undercooked. Or misaligned with the moment.

This summer, take a little time to look back, not to dwell but to rediscover. Great campaigns, like great summers, often come from second chances and a willingness to try something again, only just a little differently this time. So, you got a campaign graveyard? Dig it up. Rework it. You might just find your next big summer win buried there, waiting for its moment.

Brand messaging is the foundation of the relationships your company makes. Whether it be with potential or current consumers, staff, partners, or investors, healthy relationships are crucial to successful brand operations. Just like any relationship, communication is the binding force that brings us together and helps us achieve our goals. The choices that a brand makes regarding vocabulary, tone and style can make or break connections with relevant audiences. 

Consistency Creates a Cohesive Brand Identity

Before crafting any marketing materials, a brand needs to discover and strengthen its unique identity. By having a firm grasp on what your brand represents, every step moving forward has guidelines to work off of.  

This includes determining the feel of your brand — what tone do you want to approach your audiences with? Whichever mood you focus on should be prevalent throughout your marketing materials. This means carefully choosing words and phrases that go along with your tone. The more you push this identity to audiences, the more their familiarity with your efforts will increase. Familiarity often transforms into dependability, strengthening your brand reputation. 

Clear and Transparent Communication Shows Reliability 

Audiences won’t support a brand they don’t trust — it’s as simple as that. Choosing a brand to engage with depends on many factors, such as product quality, pricing and brand values. But how do audiences learn this information? That’s up to how the brand decides to tell them.  

If consumers can’t clearly learn who you are and what you stand for, they may view you in a lesser light, or not even give you any more of their time. This can easily be avoided by thoughtfully crafting your brand messaging, removing fluff and other factors that take away from your main points. When you know who you are as a brand, you can communicate it more clearly to your target market. When audiences recognize that you’ve put the time and effort into defining your brand, and you convey these values clearly, they’ll see you as more established and reliable each time they interact with you.  

Empathy and Relatability Make Your Brand Human 

Most industries are overwhelmed with competition, with each company looking for ways to differentiate themselves from the others to win over consumers. While it’s more important than ever for brands to capture the attention of target markets quickly, it’s just as crucial to nurture relationships and build consumer loyalty. Like with any relationship, a brand must be readily available to talk with its audiences.  

People value the authenticity of a personal touch and are more likely to engage in friendly conversations than with robotic, automated messages. Whether it’s crisis management or customer service, the customer experience should always feel approachable and genuine. While methods may vary based on company resources, brands should prioritize accessible and direct communication with consumers, as adopting a natural, conversational tone can encourage higher engagement and increased customer loyalty. 

Speak Clearly, Connect Deeply

Brand messaging is the cornerstone of all company relationships. Audiences learn about your brand from what you tell them, so first impressions — and each impression after that — are everything. By prioritizing consistency, reliability and empathy in your messaging and approach, your marketing materials will prove why audiences can confidently supporting your brand. 

The Super Bowl is one of the biggest sporting events of the year, drawing in millions of viewers worldwide. Even if your team didn’t make it, the game offers something that everyone can look forward to: commercials. Super Bowl commercials have become a main talking point in pop culture, with some people caring more for the ads than the game. Since these ad placements are such a big investment, companies are very particular about the message they want to share. There are many lessons to be learned from some of the most successful Super Bowl ads in past years.

Emotion Drives Engagement

Just like any good story, most Super Bowl commercials center around a well-developed plot. The Farmer’s Dog delivered one of the top-rated ads in 2023, showing the story between a girl and her dog. The ad highlights their evolving relationship, tapping into the ‘dog is man’s best friend’ theme to evoke an emotional response.

A campaign can benefit from targeting emotions. Depending on your product, your message, and your brand voice, the emotions you focus on may vary. But ultimately, audiences are more likely to remember information when it’s given to them as a narrative, especially if they feel personally connected to the storyline.

Sometimes Risks Pay Off

Since so many companies put their all into Super Bowl ads, it may seem difficult to take a risk. In reality, many successful commercials have appealed to viewers by surprising them. Tubi’s commercial in 2023 sent viewers into mass panic with a design that looked like someone was changing the channel. Even though the prank only lasted for a few seconds, viewers expressed online the stress they felt while scrambling for their remotes.

Even though people had mixed feelings toward Tubi after that commercial, it is still talked about two years later. Tubi took a different approach from relying on humor or emotion to grab viewers’ attentions. Similarly, marketers shouldn’t be afraid to push boundaries in their campaigns. When they assess potential outcomes, the buzz from a bold campaign can attract more attention and curiosity.

Cross-Media Consumption

For many viewers, a TV won’t be the only screen they’re focusing on during the game. Audiences have become more likely to watch the game while also focusing on their phones, laptops or other devices. With the increasing impact that social media has on consumers, as well as the desire to reach new audiences, companies have started to expand their Super Bowl campaigns to different platforms. For example, Olay’s 2020 commercial aimed to inspire women to “Face Anything,” incorporating celebrity cameos and emotional storytelling to drive the message. Olay encouraged viewers to use the hashtag #MakeSpaceForWomen on social media, vowing to donate one dollar (up to $500,000) for each use in a given time frame. This not only increased Olay’s impressions and audience engagement, but significantly strengthened their brand image.

It’s important for companies to know where their audiences are engaging with content online. Understanding different platforms and media outlets ensures that your message is reaching as much of your target audience as possible. Like the Olay commercial, this may go past simply posting the same content across channels. Giving users interactive opportunities makes them feel involved with the brand and the message your campaign hopes to convey. Fostering that feeling of community is key to increasing retention rates and building trust with your consumers.

Like Super Bowl commercials, marketers should hope that their efforts generate positive buzz for and increased attention on their client or company. Giving viewers an experience they’ll remember is crucial to improve engagement and push your message. Even if you’re not developing a campaign for the big game, it’s important to give each project the same care and attention to detail. Trust in your work and produce content that you, as a consumer, would be excited to talk about.  

The narrative of your brand storytelling and messaging builds an emotional connection with customers and clients — and should not be overlooked. This is a powerful marketing tool you can use to differentiate your brand from your competition, and so much more. Once upon a time can grow a brand from a garage band to a full symphonic orchestra. From a video on a phone to a full-fledged blockbuster movie, and happily ever after.

Strengthening Brands Through Storytelling

Recently, two new clients reached out to us to strengthen and grow their brands. These two leaders — one a mid-sized manufacturer and the other a non-profit founder — realized their vision and mission weren’t being articulated strong enough. Their narratives were powerful, but were not being communicated in the most impactful way both internally and externally.

And these business leaders knew Front Porch Marketing would activate their superpowers to propel their brands to realize business results. These results included internal alignment, engagement, increased brand awareness and increased revenues.

Over the holidays, I was reminded of the power of storytelling by watching movies and listening to music.

Storytelling Connects Us Using Music and Movies

Courtesy of my daughter’s prompting, she and I enjoyed watching movies and listened to great music over the holidays, among other things. These experiences always remind me of the power of brand storytelling. And the success so many brands have had by doing it well.

Memorable Storytelling From Past to Present

“Let’s go to the movies, Annie,” to quote the great Daddy Warbucks. Growing up, my parents took me to musicals at The Muny and The Fabulous Fox in St. Louis, Missouri. One of the many shows I saw was Annie. My middle name before I got married was Ann. My mom thought it was cute to call me Annie any chance she could.

Wicked … the movie vs. the musical? From an early age, I was hooked on The Wizard of Oz. It could have been the ruby slippers. Who doesn’t love a good shoe? I cast myself in the garage version of The Wizard of Oz. I still can recall most of Dorothy Gale’s lines. But I had no idea what happened before Dorothy followed the yellow brick road. Whoa, there was a lot. And thanks to Wicked the musical I know the story behind the story. It was genius storytelling.

And, then came the movie this year. And it was only part one. Sign me up for part two right now. And kudos to all things Wicked the movie. The actors, the sets, the music. All of it.

Stories I’ll Remember From This Year

Red One, I thought it was brilliant. Who doesn’t want the Rock and that Captain America to save Christmas? An E.L.F. — Extremely Large and Formidable — operative joining with the world’s most accomplished tracker. As well as all the other special forces for the tooth fairy and other mystical creatures. To quote Jimmy Fallon, “Come on, bud.” So good.

And, the explanation of the North Pole? “Beam me up, Scotty.” The North Pole is a much cooler place than I ever imagined — such imaginative storytelling in this movie. The portals in the toy shop! I told Audrey I was going to start working at one. She didn’t think that was a good idea. And as far as Santa’s reindeer go, this is the only movie that I can recall that portrayed them so well. They are true forces of nature. That movie was a master class in storytelling!

Oh, and of course, Taylor Swift was a highlight of our holiday experience this year, again due to my daughter. She brought Taylor’s music back into my life. Also, thanks to my sweet girl, we have a forever memory of attending The Eras Tour in Miami, Florida. Um, excuse me for this but, “It was rare. I was there. I remember it.”

Telling The Right Story Endears Audiences

Taylor Swift is the GOAT of storytelling. She somehow connects with both an 11-year-old and a, cough, 50- something adult, in similar and different ways. Long live her words, music, talents, vision, inspiration and engagement. She is the epitome of bold, memorable storytelling.

If you are in doubt, listen to The Tortured Poets Department, which much to my daughter’s chagrin I sometimes call The Tortured Poets Society, because of my age (Dead Poets Society). I am sure the great Taylor Swift knows the magic of this movie, and realizes the impact that it had on a generation.

Waxing lyrical about brand storytelling and messaging through the lens of my holiday happenings seems like a great way to start the year on a positive note. I hope this idea of storytelling resonates with you too. If so, let us know. Or, share it with a business or nonprofit leader you know who wants to grow their businesses beyond a garage band.

Collaboration is inevitable, whether in our careers, schooling or social life. This past semester I have worked to find balance between my schooling and work. Through this, I’ve gained valuable insight into how brainstorming, critiques and suggestions are all necessary to reach meaningful results.  

Growing up, I had a difficult time taking suggestions or criticism of my work. I was quite a perfectionist in that I couldn’t help but feel that any critiques were slightly personal. Yet, as I’ve grown creatively and gotten to work with other talented creatives, I’ve shifted my perspective on collaboration. My mindset has changed from previously becoming discouraged to now feeling motivated to improve. Here are some tips that have stuck with me that I keep in mind during any project I work on.  

Tip 1: Critiques are not a Criticism of your Creativity 

In my graphic design course, my work is regularly displayed to the class for my classmates to comment on. Going into my first critique session, I was terrified for my work to be perceived by others. But after listening to the critiques and making the changes to my work, I’m able to see both aesthetic and practical improvements. This has shown me that critiques should not undermine your creativity. Ultimately, you’ve already done the work that becomes the base for any critiques you may receive. You were able to create something worth discussing and that people want to see grow to its best potential. No project is perfect from the jump, and sometimes it takes multiple sets of eyes to notice things you haven’t.  

Tip 2: Don’t Hold Back Ideas  

Growing up, I tended to hold back my ideas unless I felt confident that they would impact the conversation at hand. I became hard on myself when it came to brainstorming, often thinking that if I shared an idea people didn’t use, it was a waste of time. Recently, I’ve come to learn how harsh I was on myself and now understand the value of sharing any relevant ideas that come to mind. You never know whether your idea will have that big impact unless it’s shared, and if it doesn’t, that’s ok! Most of the time, our ideas become catalysts for others to expand their thought process. Great solutions are discovered from bouncing ideas off of one another.  

Tip 3: Push Yourself to Think Past the Safe Choice 

The most important thing to ask yourself when working on a project is if the work is a good reflection of your company. This requires you to consider your audiences and stakeholders, recognizing what they want from your business and prioritizing that. By fully understanding your audience, you can experiment creatively with your messaging. Although it’s important to stick to a cohesive brand voice, don’t be afraid of creating content outside your norm. This could mean hopping onto current trends or trying out a new advertising campaign; regardless, audiences want to see fresh, entertaining content. This is another area in which conversation is key. Speaking with others and gathering multiple opinions is the best way to grow creatively without straying away from your brand image. 

Collaboration is the backbone of the creative process. With each critique or suggestion, we learn more about our craft and improve our skills. It’s important to trust those around you, for that trust fosters innovation and can motivate groups to work towards a common goal. So, don’t be afraid to speak your mind, ask questions and learn from others — you never know which ideas will spark successful content. 

Small business owners pour their hearts into their businesses, so it’s no surprise that branding and messaging often feel deeply personal. But here’s the truth: effective marketing isn’t about what you like — it’s about what resonates with your audience. A message that caters to your audience’s needs, desires, and emotions is what drives connection, loyalty, and sales.

Yet, business owners sometimes unintentionally center their messaging on themselves or their products, missing opportunities to truly engage with their target audience. Shifting focus to your audience helps avoid two common pitfalls: talking too much about yourself and focusing solely on the product.

Why Audience-Centric Messaging Matters

Think about your favorite brands. Do you love them because they talk about how great they are? Or do you love them because they speak directly to your needs, solve your problems, or make you feel something?

Great messaging connects with people by addressing their emotions, solving their pain points, or helping them imagine a better future. It says, “We see you, and we’re here for you.” For small businesses, this means stepping back and crafting a message that puts your customers in the spotlight — not you or your product.

When you shift your perspective this way, your messaging becomes more relatable and impactful, fostering stronger relationships with your audience.

Pitfall 1: Talking Too Much About Yourself

It’s natural to feel proud of your accomplishments as a business owner. Maybe you’ve built something from the ground up, developed expertise in your field, or created a product you truly love. But when your messaging focuses too heavily on you, it can alienate your audience.

Statements like:

• “We’re the best in the business.”
• “Our founder has 20 years of experience.”
• “I wanted to create something that reflected my vision.”

…don’t tell your audience what’s in it for them. Instead, shift the focus with language like:

• “You deserve the best service, and we deliver it.”
• “You’ll benefit from two decades of expertise, ensuring a seamless experience.”
• “This product was designed with your needs in mind, to make your life easier.”

This doesn’t mean you should erase yourself from your brand entirely. Your story can add authenticity and personality, but it should always serve the audience. For example, share your “why” in a way that connects with their values:

• “As a busy parent, I know how hard it can be to find safe, eco-friendly toys. That’s why I created this line — to give families like yours peace of mind.”

Pitfall 2: Focusing Messaging Solely on the Product

The second common misstep is centering your message entirely on the features of your product or service. While features are important, they’re not the primary reason people buy something. They buy based on how the product makes them feel or because of the problem it solves.

Let’s say you own a coffee shop. Instead of simply advertising:

• “We serve organic, fair-trade coffee roasted in-house.”

Focus on what that means for the customer:

• “Start your morning with a cup of coffee you can feel good about—delicious, sustainable, and crafted just for you.”

Or, if you’re promoting a skincare line, shift from:

• “Our moisturizer contains hyaluronic acid and SPF 30.”

To:

• “Feel confident in your skin all day long with hydration that lasts and sun protection you can trust.”

The key is to connect features with benefits. Features tell what the product does; benefits explain why that matters to your audience.

How to Shift Your Messaging Focus

1. Start with Empathy: What are your audience’s pain points, goals, and values? Make these the foundation of your messaging.
2. Use “You” Language: Speak directly to your audience. Replace “We” and “I” with “You” wherever possible.
3. Test Your Messaging: When reviewing your messaging, ask yourself, Would my target customer care about this? If the answer is no, refocus on what matters to them.

Build a Connection, Not a Lecture

Your brand’s messaging isn’t for you — it’s for your audience. By shifting your focus from self-promotion and product features to addressing your audience’s needs and emotions, you can create marketing that truly resonates. Remember: it’s not about telling your story; it’s about how your story fits into theirs. When you prioritize their perspective, you’re not just selling — you’re building a relationship that lasts.

During my senior fall semester at the University of Arkansas, I am taking courses that challenge my creative thinking. One of my courses, Creative Strategy, focuses entirely on developing an advertising strategy for a client of our choice. After defining target audiences and brainstorming strategic approaches, we reached the central reason for the course: writing our creative strategy statement.  

What is a creative strategy statement? 

This statement defines the purpose of a campaign and identifies how advertising and marketing efforts will benefit target consumers. Each aspect of a campaign should consider how it can bring value to its audience, and this strategy statement helps make ideas more tangible and attainable.  

How should you prepare to write one? 

Before writing this statement, the campaign team needs to have conducted the necessary research. The creative strategy statement is a great tool to guide advertising strategy and development, so it’s important to properly prepare to write it. This means taking time to define key elements of the campaign, which can be done by: 

• Customer research: Who are your current and potential consumers? What can you learn from their behaviors that may dictate how this new campaign appeals to an audience? 
• SWOT analysis: A SWOT analysis is a classic method for analyzing your brand – and for good reason. Writing out the benefits and challenges that your brand faces compared to competitors can help you discover innovative ways to meet consumer needs. 
• Current advertising approaches: Looking at and dissecting current advertising can reveal a lot about what works and what doesn’t. From analytics to behavioral reactions, there are multiple ways that a brand can strengthen its advertising presence. Then, the brand can become more distinguishable by ditching what’s not working and enhancing what is. 

What should it include? 

These statements should be succinct, only using a few sentences to provide relevant information. Developing these statements may look different depending on the client or the campaign, but important details include: 

• A description of the target market: Who do you want to reach, and what characteristics are necessary to consider when developing material? 
• Benefits offered: Why should your target audience pay attention to this campaign? What value can they get out of it that incentivizes action?  
• Customer need addressed: Offering benefits is only important if they directly and positively impact the consumer. What need does the target market have that the campaign can satisfy? 

What does this statement mean for the campaign? 

The information provided in this statement connects the strategic with the creative. Writing out the necessary details provides the parameters that advertising and marketing materials need to guide them. This statement can also help a team ensure they have thoroughly and accurately identified the target market, selling argument and tone of the campaign.  

As I enter the second half of my fall semester, the course is shifting to the development of creative work. From magazine ads to a digital ad series, my work from now on will be guided by the creative strategy statement. By combining research and recognizing the needs to be addressed, the statement is a great tool to ensure campaign materials are cohesive and on strategy.  

A brand’s visual identity is more than a logo or color palette —  it’s the visual representation your business’s values, mission, and personality. For small businesses and non-profits, a well-crafted identity builds recognition and trust. However, as these organizations grow and evolve, branding may need to change to reflect new goals, audiences, or offerings.

Why Evolve Your Visual Identity?

The decision to update or overhaul a visual identity often stems from growth or change. Here are key reasons a brand might evolve:

1. Business Expansion: As businesses introduce new services or products, their branding may no longer reflect the full scope of their offerings.
2. Shifting Target Audience: As the organization grows, its audience may broaden, requiring visuals that appeal to a wider or different demographic.
3. Modernization: Visual trends change over time, and keeping a brand fresh ensures it remains relevant.
4. Increased Professionalism: Many small businesses and non-profits start with DIY branding. As they mature, a polished identity can better reflect their level of professionalism, and dial up the credibility.

Key Elements of a Visual Identity

When evolving a brand’s visual identity, several components come into play:

1. Logo

The logo is the anchor of a brand’s visual identity. A redesign might simplify or modernize it while maintaining familiar elements for consistency. Updating or streamlining symbols can make a logo more versatile and contemporary.

2. Color Palette

Color evokes emotion and conveys values. Refreshing a brand’s color palette can help better align it with the organization’s current mission. Updating colors to align with trends can also modernize a brand’s visual identity.

3. Typography

Fonts communicate personality and tone. As businesses mature, they may shift from playful fonts to more professional ones. Introducing new fonts or pairing complementary styles can enhance both readability and brand perception.

4. Imagery and Graphics

Visuals, such as icons and patterns, help communicate the brand’s personality. Evolving these elements to align with the brand’s current focus ensures a cohesive look. For instance, non-profits may shift from abstract graphics to real-world photography as they grow their impact.

The Visual Identity Refresh vs. Rebrand

When evolving a visual identity, it’s important to determine whether your organization needs a refresh or a full rebrand. A refresh updates key elements (like colors or fonts) while keeping the core identity intact. This option is ideal for businesses looking to modernize without losing recognition. A rebrand is a complete overhaul, suitable for organizations undergoing significant shifts in their focus or mission.

Impact of a Refreshed Visual Identity

A refreshed visual identity signals growth and professionalism. It can attract new customers or supporters and keep your existing audience engaged. Modernizing your brand positions you as adaptable and forward-thinking, creating stronger emotional connections with your audience. Evolving with purpose is the goal.

For small businesses and non-profits, evolving a brand’s visual identity is about aligning with new goals and audiences. Thoughtful updates can amplify your message, improve recognition, and ultimately lead to greater success. Whether you’re expanding your business or growing your non-profit’s impact, evolving your visual identity ensures you stay relevant and resonate with the people you serve.

In marketing, innovation in creativity is crucial; but can you measure creativity? How do you know if a logo, ad, website, or campaign is truly successful? Is it just about likes, shares, and clicks, or is there something else we should be measuring? Success and impact can be interpreted in many different ways depending on the goals of the creative.

Defining Success: Start with Clear Goals

Before you establish KPIs (key performance indicators), the most important question to ask is:

“What does success look like for THIS creative project?”

This question should be at the heart of any creative brief. Without a clear definition of success upfront, it’s impossible to measure the effectiveness when you measure creativity.

For some clients, success might mean brand awareness. For others, it could be about changing consumer behavior. Creative work designed to boost sales will have different measures of success compared to one focused on building a brand. Defining goals early on ensures the creative team can craft work that aligns with the client’s expectations and makes measuring success straightforward.

Measure Creativity for Excellence and Business Results

Creatives naturally focus on the artistry behind the work — how visually compelling, emotionally resonant, or innovative it is. And while creativity is essential, it’s important to balance artistic excellence with business objectives. After all, the goal is to create work that not only looks amazing and speaks in brand voice, but also delivers results like lead generation and sales.

Key Metrics for Measuring Creativity Success

Here are some of the key KPIs to look at when measuring creativity:

Brand Awareness Metrics

Impressions and Reach: This tells us how many people saw to the creative. It is important for brand awareness projects, where the goal is to get the brand in front of as many eyes as possible.

Brand Lift Studies: These studies measure the increase in awareness or perception of a brand after exposure to a campaign. They are valuable tools for understanding how well a campaign has boosted brand recognition.

Engagement Metrics

Clicks, Likes, Shares, and Comments: While these metrics are often the most visible, they shouldn’t be the only indicators of success. High engagement shows that the audience is interacting with the content, but it’s important to dig deeper. Are the comments positive? Are the shares coming from your target audience?

Time Spent on Content: Measuring how long users spend interacting with your content, such as watching a video or visiting your website (bounce rate), can give a more meaningful indication of engagement.

Conversion Metrics

Click-Through Rate (CTR): This metric tracks the percentage of users who clicked on a link or call to action (CTA). It’s a good indicator of how well the creative has inspired action.

Conversion Rate: This is the ultimate measure of success focused on driving sales, sign-ups, or other actions. It tells us how many users completed a desired action.

Cost Per Conversion (CPC): For performance-driven campaigns, this metric reveals how efficient it is in driving conversions. A lower CPC means the campaign is delivering results cost-effectively.

Behavioral Change Metrics

Customer Retention and Loyalty: If the goal is to change consumer behavior or build long-term loyalty, metrics like repeat purchases, subscription renewals, or increased usage of a service are essential.

Survey Responses and Brand Sentiment: This analysis (e.g., using social listening tools) can help measure shifts in consumer perception, loyalty, or trust in the brand.

Return on Investment (ROI)

Sales and Revenue Impact: Ultimately, many campaigns are judged by their impact on sales. Calculating the ROI helps determine if the investment in creative development and media spend led to an increase in revenue or profitability.

Attribution Models: It’s crucial to understand which touchpoints in a multi-channel campaign contributed to conversions. Attribution models help allocate credit to different parts of the campaign, giving a clearer picture of which parts are driving success.

The Intangible Impact When You Measure Creativity

Not all success can be measured by numbers. Some of the most important outcomes of creative work are harder to track with traditional metrics. For instance:

• Cultural Relevance: Did the creative become a part of the cultural conversation? Was it referenced in media or among consumers in a way that went above and beyond the initial goals?
• Emotional Resonance: Did the creative evoke the desired emotional response from the audience? Creativity that strikes a deep emotional chord can lead to lasting brand loyalty, even if it’s not immediately measurable in terms of clicks or sales.

Long-Term Impact of Creative: The Bigger Picture

Creative success doesn’t always show up immediately. In many cases, especially with brand-building or perception-changing campaigns, the true impact is felt over time. That’s why it’s important to continue to monitor brand health metrics. Surveys, focus groups, and long-term tracking studies can reveal shifts in brand loyalty, sentiment, and customer behavior that directly correlate with marketing and creative efforts.

Overall, creative work’s goal is to inspire, engage, and ultimately drive action. But it should also contribute to the long-term success of the brand. When measuring creativity with both short-term and long-term impact, we can truly understand the value of creative efforts and continue to refine approaches to deliver even greater results in the future.